Q&A, by Vikas Swarup, came highly recommended to me by my sister. Normally I wouldn’t trust anyone who’s related to me, but I made an exception here.

The book tells the story of Ram Mohammad Thomas, a poor uneducated waiter from Mumbai, India, who miraculously answers all twelve questions on the new game show “Who Wants to Win a Billion.” The story opens with Ram in custody and the police working with the producers of the show to determine how Ram managed to cheat everyone and win a prize that the producers are not able or prepared to pay (and didn’t intend to have to pay for quite some time). A lawyer mysteriously appears at the jail offering to represent Ram and is able to have him released, at least temporarily.
The scene shifts to Ram and his new lawyer, Smita, at her house, and she begs him to explain to her how he was able to answer all of the questions on the program. After some initial hesitation, he begins to explain to her, one-by-one, how he knew the answers to the questions. And the basis of his knowledge for each question forms a single chapter in the book, as Ram tells Smita the story of a chapter in his life, in which events occurred leaving some nugget of knowledge in his brain which ended up being the answer to his question.
That idea is sort of like the dreams many people have about “Jeopardy”, or “Who Wants to Be a Millionaire?”, in which even people who aren’t particularly “book smart” just know in their hearts that if they were to get onto the show, there’s a chance that every question would fall right into their tiny little wheelhouse: the woman who’s only taken one vacation in her life, to the Grand Canyon, would get a question about the Grand Canyon. The man who did a science fair project in high school on the planet Mercury would get a question about Mercury. And so on.
Except in this case, most of the answers to the questions given to Ram took him back to very difficult times in his life, growing up as an orphan who was witness to countless tragedies involving almost everyone around him.
I’ll confess that it was at times difficult to connect the dots of Ram’s story, which wasn’t told in chronological order (it would have been a little too much of a coincidence, I think, if the questions asked of him tracked perfectly with the trajectory of his life). But each chapter could for the most part stand on its own, almost as a short story. It’s not until near the end of the book that certain elements begin to come together cohesively, explaining to the reader how he ended up in Mumbai and on the game show in the first place.
This is not an earth-shattering work. But at the same time, there’s nothing wrong with it. For some reason, though, I just didn’t feel connected to Ram or the other characters in this book the way I have in books that deeply affected me. And I don’t believe it’s a cultural thing, either. The Kite Runner and Shadow of the Wind were both books that took place in foreign countries with which I had little familiarity with customs, history, etc., and yet I felt drawn to their characters and moved by their lives. With Ram, on the other hand, I just kind of read along and whatever happened happened. It’s not that I didn’t care, but rather that the only reason I cared was for the sake of the story, and not for the sake of the people in the story.
I won’t get on a soapbox and tell everyone to go read this book, and I also won’t steer anyone away from it. I have a feeling that this book could be more impactful for others than it was for me. If anyone wants to read it, I’d love to hear their thoughts.