My book-club selection this month was The Madonnas of Leningrad by Debra Dean. Marina Buriakov is an 82 year old Russian immigrant afflicted by Alzheimer’s disease. The novel flits back and forth between the current day in which Marina can not even remember whether she has eaten breakfast or recognize her own daughter and the siege of Leningrad at the beginning of WWII where her family ended up living in the basement of the Hermitage.
Marina was a tour guide in the Hermitage when the war broke out and was responsible for packing up for storage the thousands of paintings, statues and art works that the Hermitage housed. The siege of Leningrad devastated the population many whom nearly died of starvation and Marina had to to eat the glue from the picture frames to survive. The book is filled with many references to famous works of art and conveys how the beauty of art can provide solace during the worst of times.
THE +
- Good descriptions of many works of art
- Describes Alzheimer’s and how much more devastating the disease is for the family members than for the patient
THE -
- Overall, was uninterested in any of the characters, even Marina
- Had no real ending and didn’t link Marina’s past and life as an American together
- Boring and just didn’t float my boat
I’m lukewarm on this book and unless you have any interest in Alzheimer’s or Leningrad -pass.
August 28th, 2007 at 9:25 am
OK. That’s one for the “Not TBR” stack. Anything that I can eliminate is helpful.
August 28th, 2007 at 10:08 am
I love the new format you’re using, Nicole. These reviews have been outstanding posts.
August 28th, 2007 at 11:59 am
Thanks Herm for the nice plug. I was feeling a little lazy but think that the brevity will help increase my posting output.
August 29th, 2007 at 12:02 pm
can’t disagree more. Face it, Nicole, people with alzheimer’s cannot remember what is happening now. Dean draws the picture clearly. Only happy for you that this is so foreign to you. Others are not so fortunate, and for thos of us who have been to the Hermitage, this is a terrific book on all counts. I make it a must read- and I’m a bookseller in an indpependent bookstore with access to lots of books. This is on my top 10 for 2006.
August 30th, 2007 at 4:26 pm
Uh-oh. You pissed off the Alzheimers-Leningrad Lobby.